THE STEELE DEAL TESTIMONY - HB2106, HB2107, HB2108

 

April 9, 2024. 

Testimony to Pennsylvania House Game and Fisheries Committee for Informational Meeting on HB2106, HB2107, HB2108.

Ladies and Gentlemen, Members

My name is Kevin Askew, I am the executive director for Hunters United for Sunday Hunting, the lead organization working to end the archaic blue law prohibiting hunting on Sunday.  Our mission:  Remove the prohibition of Sunday Hunting in PA Title 34 Game Law through education, and influence legislatures to change the law accordingly.  This educational effort has brought us to this meeting today regarding Pennsylvania House Bills 2106, 2107, and 2108; the Steele Deal as it is now being called.

How did we get here?  Simple, by Representative Mandy Steele doing her due diligence for eight months listening, learning, and having conversations on how to help grow the booming outdoor industry in PA while also assisting agriculture in its goals.  Hunter-conservation identified their number one issue as removing the prohibitive blue law restricting hunting on Sunday.  Agriculture identified its number one issue as being economic locally and as a whole through losses associated with crop damage.

As you are aware there is much crossover between the hunter-conservation community and the agriculture community.  That is why the inclusiveness of the Steele Deal is a solid piece of legislation. 

HB2106 removes the blue law prohibiting hunting on Sunday and provides the Pennsylvania Game Commission with full regulatory authority to set seasons and bag limits seven days a week. HB 2106 also strengthens trespass laws by outlining the requirements and responsibilities for landowners and hunters alike.

HB2107 merely finishes what has been started.  It is known the PGC has been working towards a revision and updates to the hunter agriculture crop damage system.  Be it that all legalities and mechanics for implementation can be worked out.  HB2107 finishes the puzzle of connecting hunters, agriculturalists, and farmers by creating an online network to streamline the process for better interaction and results for those farmers seeking help with crop damage.

HB2108 is a hunter-conservation and agriculture mission multiplier when viewed and interpreted correctly.  There are currently two sitting agriculturalists on the PGC Board of Commissioners.  HB2108 updates and provides the needed defining criteria for the best selection possible for the most qualified candidate.  That applicant will now have to meet the criteria of being knowledgeable in the area of wildlife management as well as actively engaged in a normal agricultural operation as defined in the Right-to-Farm Law.

During my tenure, one of the common suggestions that myself and my team have received from legislators is ‘that the hunter community and the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau need to work together. Bring us a deal that you all can agree to.’  We thank Representative Steele for getting us to this point.  Abraham Lincoln said; “The dogmas of the quiet past are inadequate to the stormy present. The occasion is piled high with difficulty, and we must rise with the occasion. As our case is new, so we must think anew and act anew.”

Together the Steele Deal legislative sponsors, hunter-conservation, the Pennsylvania Game Commission, and the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau have risen to the occasion, thought anew, and acted anew.   The expectation is that you and your colleagues will do the same.  This is not a partisan political issue of Democrat versus Republican.  It’s a Commonwealth issue of doing the right thing and ending the 342-year-old blue law and the 50-year benign seven-day-a-week hunting issue. 

The Steele Deal is a good deal; it provides for everything needed, not everything wanted. The question is do you have the insight to see this bipartisan issue as it is and get it to the Governor's desk for signature into law?  History indicates that you do. 

Thank you for your time. 

///Kevin B. Askew///

Executive Director, Hunters United for Sunday Hunting

Reference:

The outdoor industry [including hunting/shooting/trapping] added more value to our commonwealth’s gross domestic product than all of Pennsylvania’s farms, all of Pennsylvania’s oil and gas wells, and even all of Pennsylvania’s lawyers.  2021 Bureau of Economic Analysis, US Department of Commerce.

PA House Bill 2106 

PA House Bill 2107

PA House Bill 2108

THE STEELE DEAL - REMOVES SUNDAY HUNTING BLUE LAW, STRENGTHENS TRESPASS, DEVELOPS ONLINE NETWORK

CONTACT: Hunters United for Sunday Hunting

TELEPHONE: 717-350-6741

EMAIL: huntersforsundayhunting@gmail.com

WEBSITE: facebook.com/HuntersUnitedForSundayHunting

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE & DISTRIBUTION

Hunters United for Sunday Hunting, Hunter Nation - PA, and Keystone Conservation Action would like to issue the following statement to announce the introduction of HB2106, HB2107, HB2108 by PA Representative Mandy Steele, (D) Allegheny County.  This legislative package will: 

1. Remove the blue law prohibiting hunting on Sunday.

2. Strengthen trespass laws.

3. Connect hunters, agriculturalists, and farmers by creating an online network to streamline the process for better interaction and results for those farmers seeking help with crop damage.

4. To the extent possible in the PA Game Commissioner consideration, selection, and appointment process one of the nine commissioners be actively engaged in a normal agricultural operation as defined by the Right-to-Farm-Law and knowledgeable in the area of wildlife management. 

How we got here. 

Hunter-conservation identified their number one issue as removing the prohibitive blue law restricting hunting on Sunday.  Agriculture identified its number one issue as being economic both locally and as a whole through losses associated with crop damage. 

On January 30, 2024, PA Representative Mandy Steele (D) introduced and announced proposed legislation to remove the blue law prohibiting hunting on Sunday to provide the needed time for hunters to connect with those farmers and agriculturalists who were asking for help in controlling the wildlife from damaging their crops.  The announcement of this proposed legislation set the news cycle to abound.

A meeting was orchestrated for February 19, 2024, where all the active players had confirmed their participation; Rep. Steele, Hunters United for Sunday Hunting, Hunter Nation-PA, Keystone Conservation Action, Pennsylvania Game Commission, and PA Farm Bureau. Everyone was open, considerate, and frank and understood that any deal would have to be fair and not one-sided. That meeting set everyone on a very high-paced course to get something done. 

The days that followed allowed for everyone's concerns to be heard and addressed and produced equitable legislation for approval.  It is important to emphasize that neither group got everything they wanted they are getting what is needed as explained in the bill's memorandum and proposed legislation. 

On March 4, 2024, a final meeting was held with legal counsel to review language and make the proper corrections to meet and fit into established rules, laws, procedures, and legislative standards.  Lawyers took the rest of the week to finish the audit and finalize the documents for publication. 

The bill collection of HB2106, HB2107, HB2108 is formally announced and introduced into the legislative cycle ending 2024.

It is important to note that without the bipartisanship and willingness to work together of the above individuals and organizations, the legislative package would not exist.  This is a great example of what can happen when everyone is willing to come to the middle for a common goal.

There is much optimism and hope that this three-bill bundle will make it through the legislative process for both the PA House of Representatives as well as the PA Senate.  There is legislative support to get this done. At the root of it, this is a bipartisan political issue.  As Rep. Mandy Steele has said, “By supporting hunters, we are preserving forests, managing wildlife, and creating economic growth in Pennsylvania.”

The outdoor industry [including hunting/shooting/trapping] added more value to our commonwealth’s gross domestic product than all of Pennsylvania’s farms, all of Pennsylvania’s oil and gas wells, and even all of Pennsylvania’s lawyers.  2021 Bureau of Economic Analysis, US Department of Commerce.

###

For more information about this topic, please contact Hunters United for Sunday Hunting at 717-350-6741 or email at huntersforsundayhunting@gmail.com. 

View our Blog - https://huntersforsundayhunting.blogspot.com/

Hunters United for Sunday Hunting Mission Statement - Remove the prohibition of Sunday hunting in PA Title 34 Game Law through education, and influence legislatures to change the law accordingly.

 

LETTER FOR JOINT PUBLIC HEARING OF PA SENATE FISH AND GAME AND AGRICULTURE, RURAL AFFAIRS COMMITTEES ON CROP DAMAGE

 

Letter of submission to and for the joint public hearing to discuss crop damage scheduled October 23, 2023

PA Senate Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee

PA Senate Game and Fisheries Committee

Pennsylvania Game Commission

Pennsylvania Farm Bureau

PA Senate Agriculture and Rural Affairs Committee and PA Senate Game and Fisheries Committee - as you all discuss what can be done to help the agriculture community with their crop damage concern it comes down to two options.  First is financial and second is a long-term and sustainable solution.  The financial solution involves helping secure funding for crop loss through the established United States Department of Agriculture crop loss Noninsured Disaster Assistance Program (NAP).  This is a federal program available to all farmers.  To secure this funding it involves a legislative commitment to bring it to PA farmers for use.  The second and long-term sustainable solution is sitting in the Senate Game and Fisheries Committee right now.   Senate Bill 67 would provide full regulatory authority to the Pennsylvania Game Commission to authorize seven-day-a-week hunting.  Just like yourselves, hunter-conservationists are busy with life and work.  SB67 would provide another tool for the PGC to use so hunters can help harvest animals in a sustainable manner to assist with the over $70 million loss yearly in crop damage situations.  Farmers are trying to help themselves ninety-one percent of Pennsylvania farmers allowed deer hunting on their farms,  Farmers and hunters are working together for the common goal of less crop damage.  The best way to legislatively assist is to provide full regulatory authority to the PGC to allow the most benefit of time and days when hunters are available.  Combine that with bringing and educating the agriculture community on the USDA NAP program you have the perfect storm and path forward to the ongoing economic crop loss concern of yourselves and agriculturalists.

Pennsylvania Game Commission - as you participate in this forum understand that hunter-conservationists are standing beside you knowing the sustainability of PA’s wildlife is always top of mind and top of mission for the agency.  There is no disputing wildlife causes financial loss not only in agriculture but in other industries as well.  What also is indisputable is how sustainable hunting practices and your agency having full regulatory authority for seven-day-a-week hunting will help.  Many lawmakers are under the misguided impression that seven-day-a-week hunting will be detrimental.  As wildlife managers and conservationists, we know better.   The bottom line is farmers need hunters and hunters need farmers  As reported fencing and shooting were the only methods rated as being at least moderately effective in helping with crop damage.  This falls directly in line with the goal of SB67 and full regulatory authority to provide additional time and opportunity for hunters to harvest animals on farms helping mitigate wildlife crop damage.  This is the time to bridge the legislative body and recognize where the real help will come from and how it can be implemented.

Pennsylvania Farm Bureau - hunters want to help with the crop damage issue.  Recognizing the value of SB67 and accepting its goal will go a long way in the viability of the solution moving forward. There is no need to reinvent the wheel.  Just add another spoke to it.   Combining SB67 with the USDA NAP program creates the perfect scenario for small and large farms alike that need assistance with crop damage.  It helps financially as well as provides a long-term sustainable option.   

Letter sent and endorsed by the undersigned organizations. To discuss this contact 717-350-6741. 

/s/ Hunters United for Sunday Hunting

/s/ Hunter Nation

/s/ Keystone Conservation Action

/s/ Pennsylvania Cooperating Conservation Organizations

References: 

University of Wildlife Damage to Agricultural Crops in Pennsylvania: The Farmers' Perspective Dated 1997 / Updated listing 2023

USDA Noninsured Disaster Assistance Program (NAP) 

Pennsylvania Senate Bill 67

SB147 LAW. NOW WHAT?

Message from HUSH Executive Director

I have had a lot of people ask me ‘now what’ since the passing of Senate Bill 147.  Henry Ford said it best, “If everyone is moving forward together, then success takes care of itself.”

That’s exactly what we do - move forward. If we do not, then we are stagnant and ineffective. The fight remains the same, it hasn’t changed. The Pennsylvania Farm Bureau remains opposed to hunting on Sunday and will continue their hypocritical efforts to infringe on hunter-landowner rights all the while asking for politicians to grant exemptions and other favorable programs to farmer-landowners.

There are more hunters in this state and more than likely more hunter-landowners than there are voting farmer members of the PFB. We as hunter-conservationists just simply outnumber them. That is why we must remain consolidated in our efforts to bring this archaic blue law prohibiting hunting on Sunday to an end.
 
Politicians have learned that we have organized. The PFB has learned their dynasty is coming to an end. Their ability to hide behind PFB enabling politicians and the long-running ill-fated excuses of ‘why not’ will no longer be tolerated.   It is time that Pennsylvania entered the 21st Century in regards to hunting and conservation.

The sky has not fallen in West Virginia. There the legislature has done the right thing and ignored the West Virginia Farm Bureaus opposition and opened the state for hunting on Sunday. West Virginia is benefiting from this. If West Virginia legislators can ignore their farm bureau and reap the benefits the same can and should happen here in Pa.  

As I have previously stated. We are just getting started. This fight to bring Sunday hunting opportunities is much larger than any person or organization. It is based on our principles of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. 

You have my commitment that Hunters United for Sunday Hunting will continue in our mission to bring full regulatory authority to the Pa. Game Commission. I ask that everyone stay engaged, involved and continue the journey with us.

Let’s make 2020 the year of real hunter-conservationist change in Pennsylvania. It’s time we take conservation out of the hands of politicians and Pa. Farm Bureau and place it fully where it belongs – Pa. Game Commission.

Sincerely,

Kevin B. Askew
Executive Director
Hunters United for Sunday Hunting

WHATS GOING ON WITH SENATE BILL 147? I HAVEN'T HEARD ANYTHING.

“What’s going on with Senate Bill 147?” I have been asked this question quite frequently since the September 10, 2019, Sunday hunting public hearing held in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives Game and Fisheries Committee.
  
Currently, our national partners from the National Rifle Association and the National Shooting Sports Foundation have asked if they can handle the continued negotiations. This is an agreeable request since these organizations have the resources, knowledge, and experts that understand all the legislative work that takes place.
  
As of this writing, Senate Bill 147 sits in the Pa House Game and Fisheries Committee. The current negotiations regarding whether the request for written permission from the Pa Farm Bureau will be added or not. The PFB is requesting SB147 be amended to include written permission on the Sundays stipulated in the bill. No other days are being considered to include written permission.
  
So essentially the PFB wants lawmakers to write a law for what we already have. Under our current posting regulations, a landowner can require or not require written permission to hunt on their property. If the landowner is comfortable with verbal permission, that is completely up to the property owner.
   
So the question becomes why do we need a law to do what we already can do legally at landowner discretion.

The NRA and NSSF are working through this. Neither has agreed or disagreed with the proposal. The negotiating team is working with lawmakers to understand why they think writing a law to do what can already be done makes sense or not make sense.
  
Now to the big question. Are we going to have the opportunity to hunt this hunting season? I wish I had a solid and straight answer but I don’t. I can assure you that HUSH, NRA, NSSF, and all the of the conservations organizations involved in the Pa Sunday hunting fight are doing all we can to get hunting opportunity as quickly as possible. We know and understand what the extra time afield means to everyone.
  
We are up against politicians and their willingness to act quickly for all the right reasons. As it stands the Pa House Game and Fisheries Committee must vote, SB147 then goes to the entire Pa House for a vote, then back to the Senate for a concurrence vote, and then to the governor's desk for signature. All indications are Governor Wolf will sign the bill into law.
  
The overarching and more pressing issue is: the longer the legislators choose not to take action. The longer SB147 is held up in the process. The timeline gets extended. 

This is why it is extremely important to continue calling and emailing legislators on SB147.

I get it, everyone has been doing that for the past 18 months. Please hear and read my words.  It is because of you, supporters of Sunday hunting opportunity that SB147 is where it is and the ‘needle moved’ further than it has ever been in the past 20 years. I am asking that you continue that momentum, keep those phones ringing and the legislator's email boxes full with SB147 and Sunday hunting messages. Continue making the hunter-conservationists voice heard. 

We are close, please stay in the fight. 

Sincerely;

Kevin B. Askew, Executive Director Hunters United for Sunday Hunting

LETTER TO PA POLITICIANS - I HAVE HAD MY FILL

Thanks Joe for providing us a copy of the letter you sent to Pa. politicians.  Your frustration is not lost on any of us.  We need more of these letter being sent to politicians in this state.   

Letter from Joe - Disgruntled Veteran & Hunter
To the politicians of Pennsylvania: 

I am an army combat vet who served in Baghdad from 2003-2004. I now own a home, land and have three kids. I want to pass on the family hunting tradition. My daughter is three and even at this young age, she knows daddy loves deer. It is not uncommon for me to work six days a week with Sunday being the day I have off. Being on commission based salary, Saturday is the day I make my money. 

I find it both ironic and pathetic that I can't use the very freedom I served to protect to hunt the land I own on the only day I have off [Sunday] with my children.  Especially since the Pennsylvania Game Commission supports hunting on Sunday as a game management option. 

I want to teach my kids how to hunt, but I also want to instill ethics and morals into their lives. With Senate Bill 147 not passing this year I decided to purchase a New York state hunting license. On Sundays, I will be spending my time there.   When my children turn 12 years old, I will be taking them there as that's the age they can legally hunt in NY. 

My plan for next year if SB147 does not go through is to purchase an acre or two in NY close to the state lands that I will be hunting. This will also allow me to take advantage of lower license prices for me and my family. 

I can assure all of you politicians if we do not have full inclusion of all Sundays by the time my kids are 12 years-of-age. I will refuse to spend a dime of my money in this state [PA] when it comes to hunting. 

I have also decided to not support dairy farms in Pennsylvania.  I will make sure any money spent on dairy products for my family will be on products that come from elsewhere. I understand how that sounds but I don't care, the Pa Farm Bureau claims to represent all these farmers that are dictating what I can and can't do with my children on my private land. I know that may not make much difference but I can't in good conscience support them [farmers] knowing that a portion of that money benefits the PFB in some way.  

Please understand I am not an unreasonable person but I have had my fill. To us, hunting is very important as a family and we should not have to make a choice between hunting or summer vacations or choose a different career path to get my kids hunting. 

Thank you for your time.

Joe - Disgruntled Veteran & Hunter

PA FARM BUREAU SUNDAY HUNTING STANCE - RELIGIOUS OPPRESSION

Josh First, Jewish Faith, Saturday is a day of worship

Letter sent to Mr. Luke Brubaker, Chair of Lancaster County Farm Bureau’s Local Affairs Committee

From: Josh First

June 20, 2019

Mr. Luke Brubaker, District 8

PA Farm Bureau

680 Musser Rd

Mount Joy PA 17552

Dear Mr. Brubaker,

It is difficult to express the full amount of frustration my son and I feel due to the PA Farm Bureau's position against Sunday hunting. Like you we are religious people, but we observe Saturday as our day of rest, which prohibits us from hunting, driving cars, using phones or computers or doing much else other than attending services, Bible study, and relaxing with friends and family. That leaves us Sunday as our one weekend day to hunt, and as Isaac has gotten older we are seeing the end of his youthful outdoor opportunities before he goes off to college and moves out of our home. Maryland has Sunday hunting, so last November we went to Maryland, over three hours from our home, so Isaac could hunt deer without missing school. So it was on a Sunday morning in Maryland that my son killed his first deer, not in Pennsylvania, where he was born and has lived his entire fifteen years. Not at his family's hunting camp, where he has grown up shooting off the porch. Instead it was in Maryland, a serious inconvenience and a disconnect from what is an important rite of passage.

We own active crop land in Dauphin County and a tree farm in Lycoming County, and we would like to hunt on Sundays on our own land. We do not ask anyone for permission to hunt on their land, we are just fine with what we have. Our Dauphin County land is open to hunters we have approved. The PA Farm Bureau's opposition is the only reason Pennsylvania has not adopted Sunday hunting like the rest of the states surrounding us, and at this point, we believe the PA Farm Bureau is stealing our family's private property rights and persecuting us for our religion. I dislike saying these things, but the PA Farm Bureau's actions have put us in this position. You need to hear about the consequences of your actions.

How would you feel if you were in our shoes? I can answer for you.

You would feel terrible. You would feel like your fellow Pennsylvanians were oppressing you out of close-minded zeal, instead of making room for everyone to live happily here according to their conscience and free choices, as our state was originally founded. If you believe that the role of religion is to oppress, coerce, and deprive people, then you can guess why I eldered out of the Quaker faith decades ago. As I experienced then and now, too many Christians believe it is their duty to force others to live a certain way, instead of  demonstrating the correctness of their values and beliefs through their simple, gentle deeds and good living. That coercive behavior drives people away instead of bringing them closer, and the behavior of the PA Farm Bureau is driving me and many others far, far away from what you say your represent. If you are against other people enjoying Sunday hunting out of your own religious conviction about what is right for you, then you are shooting yourself in the foot, because you are setting a bad example by proving you believe in force, not love. Sorry to say. Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,                                                            

Josh First

**As of publication. Josh has not received a response to his letter**